Are you thinking about getting a fire pit for your backyard? Whether it’s for late-night s’mores, lazy weekend hangouts, or simply staring into flames like a caveman (no judgment), a fire pit is one of the best upgrades you can make to your outdoor space. But the big question that pops up? Should you go with a wood-burning fire pit or a gas one?
Here’s the short version:
Wood fire pits are for people who love the smell, crackle, and real-deal campfire experience.
Gas fire pits are for folks who want quick, clean, no-fuss flames at the push of a button.
Go wood if you’re after rustic charm, and don’t mind a little effort.
Go gas if convenience and cleanliness top your list.
In this article, we’ll walk through the pros and cons of each type, look at cost and maintenance, and help you pick what fits your space and lifestyle best.
Wood Fire Pits vs. Gas Fire Pits: What’s the Real Difference?
Let’s break this down. We’re talking flame vs. flame here, but the experience is totally different.
Wood Fire Pits – The Classic Choice
Wood fire pits bring that old-school vibe. You’re stacking logs, lighting kindling, and tending to flames like a backyard wizard. The smell? Amazing. The crackle? Cozy. But yeah, it takes effort.
Pros:
Real fire experience (smoke, smell, sounds—all the good stuff)
Great heat output
Cheaper initial setup
Easy to move (if it’s a standalone unit)
Cons:
Smoke gets in your eyes (literally)
Needs regular cleaning (ash, debris)
Takes time to start and keep going
It may not be allowed in some areas
Quick Tip: Always check local fire codes. Some cities ban wood-burning pits, especially in dry or high-fire-risk areas.
Gas Fire Pits – The Convenient Contender
Gas fire pits run on propane or natural gas. They’re the microwave of fire—push a button, boom, flames. Super clean. No wood, no ash, no smoke in your hoodie.
Pros:
Instant fire at the push of a button
No smoke, no ash, no mess
Easier to control the flame
Sleek designs that blend into modern patios
Cons:
Higher cost upfront
Needs a gas line or propane tank
Doesn’t have the same “real” fire vibe
Lower heat output (in many cases)
Info: Some gas fire pits require professional installation, especially if connecting to a natural gas line.
Comparison Table: Wood vs. Gas Fire Pits
Here’s a quick cheat sheet to help you decide.
| Feature | Wood Fire Pit | Gas Fire Pit |
| Setup Cost | Low | Medium to High |
| Maintenance | High (ashes, wood debris) | Low (clean and easy) |
| Heat Output | High | Moderate |
| Ease of Use | Needs effort | Push-button convenience |
| Aesthetic/Experience | Classic, natural | Modern, clean |
| Portability | Usually portable | Often fixed or heavy |
| Smell and Smoke | Yes (in a good and bad way) | None |
| Regulations | May be restricted | Usually permitted |
Conclusion
Choosing between a wood or gas fire pit comes down to what kind of experience you want. If you love building fires, don’t mind a bit of effort, and live somewhere that allows it—wood is a solid choice. If you prefer quick, clean, and easy, gas is probably your best bet.
No wrong answer here. Just fire—your way.
FAQs
Can I use a wood fire pit in the city?
Depends on your local regulations. Some cities restrict wood burning due to air quality or fire safety concerns. Always check your municipal code.
Are gas fire pits expensive to run?
Not really. A standard propane tank (about $20) can last 8–10 hours, depending on flame height. Natural gas is even cheaper in the long run.
Do wood fire pits attract bugs?
Yes—smoke can repel some, but leftover food or woodpiles can invite critters. Keep the area clean and store wood properly.
Which fire pit gives more heat?
Wood fire pits usually produce more heat. If warmth is a priority, wood’s your best bet.
Can I cook on both types?
Technically yes, but wood is better for the full BBQ/campfire experience. Many gas pits aren’t designed for cooking and can be damaged by grease or food spills.
